Home > Daily-current-affairs

Daily-current-affairs / 16 Nov 2026

Global Debate on the Death Penalty: Balancing National Sovereignty, Human Rights and Justice

Global Debate on the Death Penalty: Balancing National Sovereignty, Human Rights and Justice

Context:

Recently, India voted against a United Nations General Assembly (UNGA) resolution calling for a global moratorium on the use of the death penalty. The resolution, introduced by Mexico during the 81st session of the UNGA, sought to encourage countries to suspend executions with the ultimate objective of abolishing capital punishment. It was adopted with 133 countries voting in favour, 33 against and 16 abstaining. India's vote reflects its position that the use of capital punishment should be determined by individual countries in accordance with their domestic legal systems and national circumstances.

Key Provisions of the UN Resolution:

      • The resolution expressed concern over the continued use of capital punishment and called upon countries to establish a moratorium on executions with a view to abolishing the death penalty. It urged member states to progressively restrict its use, reduce the number of offences punishable by death and ensure that it is not imposed for crimes committed by persons below 18 years of age. It also emphasised safeguards for pregnant women and persons with mental or intellectual disabilities. Further, it encouraged countries that have abolished capital punishment not to reintroduce it.
      • The resolution is non-binding in nature and does not automatically change the domestic laws of member states.

Why Did India Vote Against the Resolution?

      • India opposed the resolution primarily on the grounds of national sovereignty and the absence of international consensus on the abolition of capital punishment. India maintains that every sovereign country has the right to determine its own criminal justice system and prescribe appropriate punishments according to its constitutional framework and socio-legal circumstances.
      • India also distinguishes between judicially imposed capital punishment after due legal process and extrajudicial or arbitrary killings. It argues that these two practices should not be treated as equivalent. Further, Article 6 of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR) recognises the continued use of capital punishment in countries that have not abolished it, subject to specific restrictions and safeguards.

Background: Death Penalty in India:

      • In India, the death penalty is constitutionally permissible but is restricted by the Supreme Court's rarest of rare doctrine, established in the landmark Bachan Singh v. State of Punjab (1980) judgment. According to this doctrine, capital punishment should be imposed only in exceptional cases where the alternative option of life imprisonment is unquestionably foreclosed.
      • The constitutional framework governing capital punishment includes Article 21, which guarantees the right to life and personal liberty, Article 72, which provides the President with the power to grant pardons and other forms of clemency, and Article 161, which provides similar clemency powers to Governors within their constitutional jurisdiction.

Global Debate on the Death Penalty

Important Supreme Court Judgments:

The Supreme Court has played an important role in regulating the use of capital punishment in India.

      • Jagmohan Singh v. State of Uttar Pradesh (1973): The Supreme Court upheld the constitutional validity of the death penalty.
      • Bachan Singh v. State of Punjab (1980): Established the rarest of rare doctrine and restricted capital punishment to exceptional cases.
      • Machhi Singh v. State of Punjab (1983): Elaborated the application of the rarest of rare doctrine by identifying factors such as the manner, motive and magnitude of the crime.
      • Mithu v. State of Punjab (1983): Struck down mandatory death penalty under Section 303 of the Indian Penal Code, emphasising judicial discretion and fairness.

International Legal Framework:

      • The issue of capital punishment is governed by various international human rights instruments. The Universal Declaration of Human Rights (1948), under Article 3, recognises the right to life. Article 6 of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (1966) regulates the use of the death penalty in countries that have not abolished it. The Second Optional Protocol to the ICCPR, adopted in 1989, aims at the abolition of capital punishment.
      • India is a party to the ICCPR but has not ratified the Second Optional Protocol.

Arguments in Favour of and Against the Death Penalty:

      • Arguments in favour: Supporters argue that capital punishment provides justice to victims and their families, serves as a possible deterrent against heinous crimes and ensures proportionate punishment for exceptionally grave offences. It is also considered by some as a means of protecting society from extremely dangerous offenders.
      • Arguments against: Critics argue that there is no conclusive evidence that the death penalty deters crime more effectively than life imprisonment. They highlight the possibility of wrongful convictions, judicial errors, socio-economic inequalities in access to legal representation and the irreversible nature of execution. It also raises concerns regarding human dignity, the right to life and the possibility of reform and rehabilitation.

Challenges Associated with Capital Punishment in India:

      • The application of capital punishment raises several concerns. Judicial errors may result in the execution of innocent individuals, while economically weaker sections may not always have access to quality legal representation.
      • Delays in deciding appeals and mercy petitions can cause prolonged uncertainty and psychological suffering. Further, inconsistencies in sentencing may result in unequal treatment of individuals involved in similar offences. These challenges highlight the need for stronger judicial safeguards and a fairer criminal justice system.

Way Forward:

India needs to adopt a balanced approach that protects the rights of victims while safeguarding the constitutional rights of accused persons. Investigation and forensic infrastructure should be strengthened to minimise wrongful convictions, and quality legal aid should be ensured for economically weaker sections. There is also a need to develop consistent sentencing guidelines, ensure timely disposal of appeals and mercy petitions, and strengthen victim compensation and rehabilitation mechanisms. The application of the rarest of rare doctrine should be reviewed periodically to ensure fairness, proportionality and consistency.

Conclusion:

India's vote against the UN resolution highlights the tension between national sovereignty and international human rights standards. While the country retains capital punishment as part of its criminal justice system, its application is restricted by constitutional and judicial safeguards. The debate requires a balanced approach that considers justice for victims, protection of human rights, the possibility of judicial errors and the principles of fairness, proportionality and human dignity.

Aliganj Gomti Nagar Prayagraj